Carriers

Dumbaugh Insurance takes pride in representing only the finest insurance providers, whether it be health coverage, commercial, or personal insurance, if you’re a client of our agency, you can reset assured that you are with a financially stable, reputable company.

Here is a list of contact information for each insurance carrier we represent.

If you need immediate assistance, we recommend contacting your company directly.

CompanyClaimsPaymentsWebsite
Aetna800-624-9326800-624-9326Online Payments
Anthem740-397-1234740-397-1234Online Payments
Cincinnati877-242-2544513-870-2000Online Payments
CNA877-262-2727877-276-7507
Online Access
Cowbell Cyber833-633-8666833-633-8666Online Access
Everett Cash Mutual740-397-1234740-397-1234Online Payments
EyeMed740-397-1234740-397-1234Online Payments
Frankenmuth800-234-4433800-234-4433Online Access
Guardian Life800-459-9401
800-459-9401
Online Access
Keystone National740-397-1234740-397-1234Online Access
Liberty Mutual800-225-2467800-824-7317Online Access
Medical Mutual740-397-1234740-397-1234Online Access
Mennonite Mutual800-678-6885
740-397-1234Online Access
Nationwide800-421-3535888-891-0267Online Access
Openly888-808-4842888-808-4842Online Access
Patriot Life866-460-1776
866-460-1776
Online Access
Philadelphia Insurance800-765-9749
800-765-9749
Online Access
Progressive800-274-4499
800-888-7764
Online Access
Safeco800-332-3226
800-332-3226
Online Access
Superior Dental800-762-3159
800-762-3159
Online Access
Superior Vision800-879-6901800-507-3800Online Access
United Healthcare888-842-4571
888-842-4571
Online Access
West Bend Insurance877-922-5246
800-573-1323
Online Access
Western Reserve800-362-0426800-362-0426Online Access
Westfield Insurance866-937-2663
800-766-9133
Online Access

Request Your Proposal Here

Are you ready to save time, aggravation, and money? The team at Dumbaugh Insurance is here and ready to make the process as painless as possible. We look forward to meeting you!

Start Here
Call Email Claims Payments