Report a Claim
We are here to help you. Please call our office with any questions, or if we can help process your claim. We handle many small claims ourselves and are happy to assist you.
Below you will find the direct claims contact information for many of our companies. If the company you need is not listed, please call our office and we will help you handle your claim immediately.
space
space
24 Hour Claim Service
Westfield Claims                                         1-866-937-2663
Westfield Claims fax                   1-866-937-2664
Westfield Glass Service                1-800-810-3665
space
Westfield Local Claims Office
2250 Village Mall Drive
PO Box 2710
Mansfield, Ohio 44906
1-800-428-0257
1-419-747-6190 fax
Monday thru Friday, 8:00am to 6:00pm
space
American Select Claims                  1-800-552-9144
American Select (After Hours)Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â 1-800-241-2541
space
space
All Cincinnati claims must be reported to our office.
Dumbaugh Insurance Agency                     1-800-574-4363
Dumbaugh Insurance Agency fax        1-740-392-0087
space
Our Cincinnati Claims Adjustor is:
Richard Feldner                                           1-419-884-0429
Richard Feldner fax                   1-419-884-8218
Cincinnati Life                                              1-800-783-4479
space
space
Claims Hours of Operation:
7:00am-5:30pm M-TH
8:00am-5:30pm F
Home, Auto, Commercial Claims:
Contact Dumbaugh Insurance Agency during normal business hours
File your claim online under our Policyholder Services section at https://secure.fmins.com/phs/PI_Index.asp
Or, call toll-free 1.800.234.4433 after hours
Auto Glass Claims: Call 1.800.234.4433
space
space
24/7  Claims Service                               1-800-925-2886
